He gets to live with it.
I really didn’t want to write something like this, but then I read “What Do We Do With Jacob Geller?”. It made me so angry I felt I had to write something. So here I am.
Let’s recap: noted YouTuber Jacob Geller sexually assaulted his then-girlfriend while at UNC, something the university suspended him for a semester for (which is a matter of public record thanks to the North Carolina Supreme Court) and something he has since admitted to. If the story, first brought to everyone’s attention by a random social media post not made by the victim, is true, Geller attempted to have sex with his girlfriend while she was unconscious. By definition, that’s rape, which makes Geller a rapist (provided, again, that account is true). Given that everything else the posts said is true, I personally believe it.
Jacob Geller, then, is guilty of sexual assault and allegedly a rapist.
I want to establish something from the outset: I have no attachment to Geller and his work. I don’t tell you this to brag or seem superior, but to establish that this will not be one of those essays in which I lament his “betrayal” of my trust or say “why can’t we have nice things” or “man, this one hurts.” If you are looking for that, you’re barking up the wrong tree. If you found value in his work, more power to you. I just want to lay out where I stand.
Here’s the funny thing, though. There are a lot of talented, successful YouTubers (and journalists) who haven’t sexuallly assaulted and likely raped someone. And we have every reason to believe Geller is a rapist.
Which is why when I first saw “What Do We Do With Jacob Geller?” my first thought was “I don’t know, have you considered a woodchipper? The guillotine? The deepest, darkest hole in the ocean? A short drop and a sudden stop? A long walk off a short pier? Gasoline and a match? Exile, forever?”
I will be very clear: I despise rapists, and I view rape as one of the two things you cannot and should not ever be allowed to come back from. Rape is not an accident; it requires intent. It is forcing yourself on, and violating the body of, another person. Nobody is accidentally a rapist. That Geller did what he allegedly did, as a 20 year old college student who had no excuse not to know better, tells me everything I need to know about who and what he is.
Part of my hatred of rapists and people who commit sexual assault comes from knowing that many people I love, men and women alike, have been raped or sexually assaulted. The other part of it involved being a college professor and seeing how common rape and sexual assault are on college campuses. I saw what it did to the people who were victims of it firsthand, and I saw brilliant young women (and it was always women) have their lives upended by men (and it was always fucking men) who rarely faced consequences for their actions. At worst, they got a slap on the wrist, just like Geller got. Maybe, if they’re really bad, they might have to write an essay.
The men who did this to the young women I knew (and all the people we don’t know) potentially destroyed the life of another person, violated them in the most profound mental and physical way. And they got to keep living like none of it ever happened. To watch this happen in real time, and be unable to do anything but be there for and support the victims as best you can while the institutions meant to protect them repeatedly fail them, will drive you mad. It will acquaint you with a level of rage powerful enough to start a truck. And I am not a victim. Imagine how those women felt. How every victim of sexual violence feels. Really try to think about it, about living with it every day, about staying in school and the possibility of walking back on to campus and seeing the person who sexually assaulted you and got away with it because we “shouldn’t ruin the lives of promising young men.” Imagine living, every day, with that hurt and that rage, and the cost – mental, physical, social, and monetary – of attempting to recover from that. What should we do with Jacob Geller? Consider the woodchipper.
But the death penalty is morally abhorrent and perpetrators of sexual violence almost never get it anyway and it seems unlikely Geller will be held legally accountable, so there have to be other ways. First, we have to establish who “we” is. One of the strongest things surrounding this whole revelation is people who watched Geller’s videos claiming they had been “betrayed” or wronged in some way. Let me be clear: you are not a victim of what Geller did. You watched a YouTube video (or several) and believed in a public persona of goodness crafted by a man who has none. This is not about you, and framing it that way is disturbing. You should consider why you need this to be about you. You may have your own personal response to Geller and his work, but there is no “we.” There is just each of us, and how we deal with it ourselves.
What’s more disturbing, however, is how many people are already trying to redeem him, to, as “What Do We Do With Jacob Geller?” suggests, offer him “restorative justice.” This is offensive on several fronts, so I’ll take them one at a time.
First, “restorative justice” is not about the perpetrator. It is about empowering the victim, who did not agree to have her trauma aired in public, and has had no say in any of this, and cannot be un-sexually assaulted. Perhaps we should focus on her before we rush to rehabilitate the man who assaulted her less than a week after it became public knowledge.
Secondly, let’s examine Geller’s actions post-sexual assault. He’s a different person now, so goes the claim. He’s put in the work to try to redeem himself. He’s a good man, right?
Are you sure?
Here is what Geller actually did: minimize, as much as he could, his involvement with UNC on his LinkedIn page. Hid, as best he could, why he missed a semester of college.
“Ah, but Will,” you might argue, “it’s not his story to tell publicly.” Sure. But surely as someone who perpetrated a criminal sex act, you might inform the people you worked with privately so they could make an informed decision about whether or not they wanted to work with someone who was allegedly a rapist and could potentially be a danger to other people around him, right? Especially after going out of your way to act like a good man. Especially when you present yourself as a person who is safe for women to be around.
Did Geller inform the folks at Cane and Rinse of what he had done? No. How about the people at MinnMax? No. Lost in Cult? No. Nebula? No. None of those organizations, or the people within them, agreed to platform or work with a man who committed, by his own admission, an act of sexual violence that was, at one point, a matter of public record. Not one. Instead, Jacob Geller swept his past under the rug so he could become a famous and successful public figure. Ask yourself this, and answer honestly: would any of these organizations have worked with Geller had they known who he really was? Would you have watched his videos? Will you watch them knowing what you know now? Would you work with him? Be in the same room with him? Shake his hand? Tell the truth.
Geller is not stupid. He wanted to be rich. He wanted to be famous. He wanted book deals and clout. He thought he deserved it, and he knew that no one who committed sexual assault would have the support necessary to achieve those things. And so he made sure nobody else knew. You’re right: these are the actions of a good man, a changed man, one who deserves “restorative justice.” We shouldn’t ruin the life of a promising young man.
Even his “apology” rings hollow. Does he admit to what he did? Sure. But we also have records from the university that he did it. There was no point in lying. Read it again. Does he apologize, publicly, to the victim who has once again had their life damaged by his actions? No. Does he apologize to the colleagues whose trust he betrayed and who image he has stained because of his association with them? No. Does he, at any point, apologize for committing sexual assault and then spending years covering it up so he could have a public-facing career that gave him fame and fortune? No. He is sorry that “this has hurt many of you.” It is the classic non-apology apology, the language of the abuser. Jacob Geller is not sorry he committed sexual assault. He is not sorry he kept it from his peers, co-workers, colleagues, or audience for a decade to further his career. He’s sorry you found out about it. He’s sorry he got caught twice.
A man who was sorry would have raised awareness. He would have set up a charity to help victims of sexual violence and donated his substantial resources to it. He would have used his wealth and success to platform women and survivors of sexual violence. He would have done the work. Instead, he chose to conceal the truth and enrich himself. You’re right; Jacob Geller is a good man, an honorable man. We should forgive him. We shouldn’t ruin the life of a promising young man.
For the first time in his life, Jacob Geller is facing the consequences of his actions. And no, the single-semester suspension doesn’t really count. Students who violate academic probation face harsher consequences and they haven’t committed a crime. Geller has been accused of having sex with his girlfriend while she was unconscious. In the state of North Carolina, that is classified as second-degree forcible rape, a felony punishable by twelve years to life in prison. Instead, Geller was suspended for a semester, and ten years later, after acquiring significant money and prestige, will no longer have his books sold, no longer be professionally associated with organizations who did not know they were working with a sexual abuser, and lose some of his massive following. As of the time of publication, Geller’s Bluesky account has lost a little more than 7,000 of its followers. It retains a little less than 60,000. My heart bleeds for him. His still hasn’t uploaded his statement admitting he committed sexual assault to his website or to his Patreon, which is, at the time of publication, making him over $6,000 a month. But you’re right. Jacob Geller is an honorable man. He’s changed. Done the work. We should forgive him. We shouldn’t ruin the life of a promising young man.
Forgiveness is between Geller and his victim, who has now likely been retraumatized without her consent. Not us. Absolution is between him and God. But we do not owe him deference, or a voice, or a place of influence in public life. We don’t owe him redemption. He has to earn that himself. What he does now is up to him. Nobody owes him their time, their association, or respect. No one is calling for his death. Maybe now he just has to be an accountant. Jacob Geller is a good man now, right? An honorable man. He’s changed. We shouldn’t ruin his life. Surely a good man can accept the consequences of his actions with grace and remove himself from the public sphere. And Jacob Geller is a good man. Right?
He will still be able to go to restaurants and the movies and play video games. He will still have all the money he made because nobody knew who – what – he was. He will get to live every day, having made the life of another person worse forever and never admitting it until he was forced to so he could get all the things he wanted. He tricked good people to do it. But it’s okay. He deserved it. He wanted it, and so he should have had it, regardless of what anybody else wanted, regardless of whether anyone else thought it was okay. Who were we, or anybody really, to tell him no, to not consent? After all, he’s a good man. Right?
What do we do with Jacob Geller? We don’t fucking kill him. No. He gets to live with it.
Skybox is worker-owned and reader-supported! If you like pieces like this, support us at www.patreon.com/skyboxcritics or ko-fi.com/skyboxcritics and help us elevate games media.
based and correct, but also if he happens to fall in the woodchipper in not gonna cry
yeah this is one of those things where on a praxis level i am adamantly against the death penalty and adamantly in favor of prison abolition, but on a personal level i won’t ever shed a tear for a dead rapist. it can be a tough square to circle for myself sometimes but i sure am not gonna do it by rehabilitating a rapist!!!! i sure am not gonna bemoan him losing the audience he gained through lying and is trying to keep through manipulation!!!!!!!!
anyway yeah based and correct
Prison Abolition is one of the most ridiculous leftist causes I have ever heard.
We need prisons. Some people can never be left out in society. The whole idea of abolishing prisons is a feel good idea for those who never want to think beyond their slogan to consider the actual consequences of what the slogan means.
We should put far fewer people in prison. Prison certainly should not be private businesses, but prisons are absolutely necessary and I really haven’t heard a single good argument for it beyond leftists wanting to feel good about themselves.
It seems I can’t reply to Duskmourne directly, or I would, but this is a response to what they said.
Part of the problem when discussing whether we need “prisons” and the reason that “prison abolition” is such a hotly debated topic is that I think we ALL agree that there is a very small number of those who have already committed severe offenses against the community, are too dangerous to be permitted unsupervised into society, and thus need dealt with. The trouble, then, is what a “prison” is, and whether to place them in a “prison”.
I am strongly against the idea of a “prison” when it means a concrete hole that is missing basic amenities. No “prisoner” should ever be denied basic human needs and a level of “creature comforts” necessity life by the state. There has to be a bed that meets the individual’s requirements for restful sleep, proper hygiene facilities, a place to perform work/recreation tasks, et cetera. A “prison” should not be a space that is punitive, it should be a space that is containing, else, we risk committing acts of environment torture on the wrongfully convicted and psychologically scarring those rightfully convicted who we will release back into society at the end of their term. Additionally, even for the worse people, the heinous and remorseless, someone has to mind them while they are in the prison. Prisons require a guard, and it’s psychologically detriment to guards to ever be in a position where they are looking after a prisoner who has been dehumanized and forced to huddle in a concrete hovel. Guards re-entry society daily, and the damage we inflict on them mentally and the behavior we encourage in guards within inhumane prisons does get back out to society. In order to keep a prisoner who committed a crime in a hellish hole, we have to condemn an innocent person there alongside them to ensure they stay in the hole.
This is why I don’t believe in “prisons”, even though I believe in containing certain people. The containment just can’t be a “prison”. Personally, I’m in favor of things like exile communities where the violent and the sexually predatory are sent to away from society to live among each other. We do this sometimes with pedophiles instead of allowing them to reintegrate into community, and similar measures could be employed for other sex offenders.
Do I want to put the sex criminals in a concrete hole? Yes, actually, I do, but it’s just been proven to be very harmful to society by traumatizing guards and the wrongfully convicted, and if you’re a victim of a sex crime by someone you know and have affection for, you’re way less likely to come forward if it means they are sent down into the misery hole, especially if you’re a child. Kids don’t want daddy to get hurt, they just want daddy to stop hurting them, and if we frame it as “we’ll hurt daddy for hurting you” many kids, especially ones who’ve internalize responsibility for their abuse, will keep the abuse hidden.
Sex predators do need to be contained to prevent a threat to others, but containment doesn’t have to be a “prison”, it can look like something humane. We do have to do something with those accused of and demonstrated to be sexually violent, it just can’t be a lightless, airless concrete hole.
Having read this and the other piece the author mentioned being angry at I can see both points, like Will I had no familiarity with Geller before the news came out so I never got that wounded sense of betrayal(not like I did with JKR after having grown up reading the HP books and watching the movies and playing the games)with him. Personally I just cannot get behind prison abolition completely, not after seeing how many monsters are out there via true crime programs like Cold Case Files and Forensic Files. Some people are just too dangerous/evil to be allowed to participate in society and deserve to spend the rest of their lives behind bars, and i’m not going to shed any tears for what happens to them in prison.
Having read this and the other piece the author mentioned being angry at I can see both points, like Will I had no familiarity with Geller before the news came out so I never got that wounded sense of betrayal(not like I did with JKR after having grown up reading the HP books and watching the movies and playing the games)with him. Personally I just cannot get behind prison abolition completely, not after seeing how many monsters are out there via true crime programs like Cold Case Files and Forensic Files. Some people are just too dangerous/evil to be allowed to participate in society and deserve to spend the rest of their lives behind bars, and i’m not going to shed any tears for what happens to them in prison.
Kiaran-personally I don’t care if some rapist or murderer is having a shitty time in prison, they don’t deserve comfort after what they’ve done, and their already exist somewhat nice prisons for those who committed minor offenses-they’re called minimum and medium security prisons. The prisons you always see on TV and movies are the maximum security ones for the worst of the worst, so forgive me if i’m exactly losing sleep over sick bastards
how exactly would “exile” even work? I don’t see any practical way to possibly enforce that, we’ve already tried that with sex offenders and that hasn’t exactly worked out, so I highly doubt exile for violent offenders would work any better. Some people deserve to be kept in a concrete hole plain and simple and i’m not going to feel sorry for them.
While this is a strong principled piece and I thank you for it, your lead-off and the general antics of the rest of social media pointing their cannons away from Geller toward someone who, at worst, just wrote an article to express their feelings is distressing. If you hated it so much, you didn’t need to link to it. People are chasing the high of throwing public figures in the woodchipper with scolding strangers who in any other setting would be aligned with them.
“scolding strangers who in any other setting would be aligned with them”
But this is the whole problem. The reason people are so willing to “forgive” Geller to begin with is because he’s politically aligned with them in every other way. You don’t get a free rape apologia ticket with your leftist politics. If you defend a man’s right to rape then it doesn’t matter to me if we agree on other issues. This idea that women need to bear the brunt of rape or accept rape apologia for the sake of the “community” needs to stop. There’s no community at all if some of its members are okay with their buddies raping women.
What strikes me is how swiftly and immediately James Somerton was relentlessly harassed and driven off the internet when his plagiarism came to light, meanwhile Geller has received little more than slaps on the wrist for rape. Colleges, too, seem to penalize plagiarists more harshly than rapists. Plagiarism is bad, sure, but rape is obviously far worse, but seemingly no one calls for ‘restorative justice’ for people who cheat on their video essays or college theses. There is no shortage of people who only seem to bring up the concept of restorative justice when women want consequences for rapists, domestic abusers, and other perpetrators of profound violence against women.
i wonder how much of it too was that james somerton was provably, demonstrably being queerphobic by stealing from queer creators. people try to cite geller’s politics as proof that he’s changed, that he’s doing good work, that we should give him a second chance, and so on and so on. james somerton was taken down by a fellow leftist who was able to showcase that this man was doing real harm to the queer community, that he was not the progressive we thought he was.
to be clear i fully agree that the societal minimization of violence against women and sexual violence, even within leftist circles, is a HUGE (and even the main) part of this, i’m just musing on other ways people might be able to contort themselves into justifying themselves here, consciously or not. they can point to the good they think geller is doing; somerton lost all such pretense.
the backlash against Somerton was also because many people already had issues with him and disliked him and felt like he had no talent, so there was no great loss of him being gone from Youtube. Whereas many people love Geller’s writing for whatever reason so it’s not as easy to throw him in the bin. I never heard of the guy before now so I have no attachment to his work whatsoever, but i’m sorry for those who did look up to him, especially other women who may have been assaulted themselves, I can only imagine how triggering finding out a famous man you looked up to turned out to be a rapist is.
Excellent article, though I want to point something out: Geller’s victim was already potentially being retraumatized every single day, because Geller chose to have a very public career. We don’t know if the victim knew that Geller was YouTube famous, but I think it’s likely that she did, and if so, that in itself is retraumatizing. I mean, just imagine seeing your rapist make a cushy living off of pretending to be a leftist feminist ally.
I say this because people are using the argument that the victim is being retraumatized to try to sweep all of this under the rug. And while I agree that the way this came out wasn’t the best, I think people are just trying to take advantage of that to stop others from talking about what Geller did. The victim has been retraumatized already. Potentially, she’s been retraumatized daily for the last decade. It’s possible that this was the only way for that to stop.
I mean, you can’t say that one way or the other. But the idea that he was pretending to be a leftist is ridiculous. It pushes the idea that leftist progressives can’t commit horrible crimes, which is absolutely ridiculous. They do every day, just like the far right. Politics is no indication of a person’s ability to commit crimes, and those crimes don’t determine their Politics.
I have no connection to Gellar, I never consumed his content aside from incidentally through a couple of Deepest Dives for the FF7 Remake series and Resident Evil. I am not really a fan of MinMaxx, or any group who spends their time lecturing others on morals.
That said, why do “we” have to do anything with Jacob Geller? We don’t owe him anything, and we don’t get to “punish” him beyond choosing to consume his content or not. I’m not going to search out his content, and I’m also not going to avoid it. If he is in a piece of content I want to watch, I will watch it.
What he did isn’t even known. To me it sounds like he had drunk sex, and somehow in 2016 if two drunk people had sex, the man was responsible for rape. For a whole generation after mine, men became responsible for the actions of women who were drunk, even when they themselves were drunk. I’ve heard the “Drunk women can’t consent” bs so many times, and all it does is take away personal responsibility. If a drunk woman can’t consent, then how can a drunk man? If this happens to be what happened, then this whole thing is a travesty. And Geller is exactly the type of leftist who would fall for and promote this kind of false narrative.
If it’s not, however, and he was sober and tried to have sex with an unconscious woman, then burn him at the stake before you throw him in the wood chipper. Unlike you, I do believe in the death penalty.
But the truth is, without having actual details I am not going condemn him, nor will I absolve him. That isn’t for me or anyone else to do without knowing the details, and we absolutely do notknow any of the details.
sounds like you have issues with women in general, misogynist creep.
I’ve seen people preach restorative justice ONLY when it comes to babying rapists in many such controversies. If anyone seriously believes in any good things about restorative justice, this repeat pattern has been an optics nuke. Its the wokespeak version of “think of this promising young person”. Its absolutely vile poison, and I’m so sorry to people who believe in things that your convictions have been so trashed.
I think back to Nick Robertson. He had a popular let’s play series on Polygon called Car Boys. Who remembers Car Boys. Robertson was outed as a sex pest, Polygon dropped him. A few months later, he made a smash hit viral video about some MacDonald’s game. Same niche, same man, new channel, new fanbase, no consequences. I’m very afraid I’ll get to see this happen a second time.
never heard of Robertson and i’m glad I didn’t, yikes.